Gamer Proves How Easy it is to Game Journalists

Gamer Proves How Easy it is to Game Journalists


The anonymous gamer who created the X-surface tumblr page does not work for Microsoft. He has no connection to them whatsoever and has no more idea then the rest of when their next console is coming out or what the details behind it will be. Nevertheless, when he sent anonymous tips out this morning to some of the major gaming news sites, most of them took the word of an anonymous tipster for fact, writing entire articles about his long, highly detailed and entirely made-up fake news: Yahoo, CNET, Gizmodo, Venturebeat, Tech Digest, VG247, and NowGamer.

What was the goal of this elaborate hoax? To demonstrate the flawed reporting process of these websites, and to show just how easy it is to get fake news to circulate. In a matter of hours a fake story had managed to spread from an unverified source to the front page of just about every major gaming and tech news site out there. Even those who didn’t write about it, sites like Polygon, IGN and 1Up, were eagerly tweeting about it, no doubt prepping stories of their own right up to the very moment the whole thing was revealed for what it was.

The mastermind has this to say on the results of his little experiment:

Many games ‘journalists’ have no right calling themselves such things. The vast majority do nothing but copy & paste from other sites, and will willingly publish information without fact checking a single thing or attempting to verify the source.

It’s all about being first. To get such news out (whether you believe it or not) before any other person on Twitter does, will guarantee you retweets, and those all-important followers. Gaming ‘journalism’ is completely broken.

By using Twitter, most writers/editors believe they can get away with spreading false information for their own benefits. They are the only ones to gain from such practices, whilst the gaming fans end up with speculation and, sometimes, outright lies.

Note that at the time of this writing, though many of the sites linked above have updated their posts to clarify that the story they reported on was proven fake, not a single one of them has felt the need to pull the story. And why would they, when every new user introduced to this misinformation earns them page clicks and ad revenue? After all, there is no such thing as bad publicity.

The prankster’s goal was to demonstrate that gaming journalism amounts to little more than copying and pasting from other sites, spreading the hot story as quickly as possible in the interest of generating as much traffic as possible. Not only are the consequences for failing to fact check nearly non-existent, but oftentimes writing about questionable or outright fake news ends up being a more profitable use of time than actually attempting to hold yourself to some standard of quality. Today the entirety of the Game Journalism community fell into the simplest and most easily avoidable of traps.

I don’t pretend that Gather Your Party always succeeds where the rest of the community fails — we don’t have the resources to go out and obtain our news firsthand after all, or to update as frequently, and we do gather the majority of our stories from other websites — but we’re certainly aware of many of the problems the industry is suffering from, and we’d like to think that we at least try to hold ourselves to a higher standard of quality. You don’t see us writing about dollhouses for example, or Japan’s obsession with 2D women, or the beer-drinking habits of a former Bioware employee. We’re a gaming website you see, so we like to keep our content related to video games. While our content can be seen to reflect our personal biases at times, and may even come across as a bit sensationalist, you can be damn sure we checked our sources, starting by making sure there is more than one. If it’s a rumor, we say so, and from where. If the rumor doesn’t look very credible, we don’t even write about it.

Though we didn’t fall for the hoax ourselves, it’s safe to say that this event will be looked at as a warning the next time some crazy rumor starts going around, and a reminder that sources should be verified before you go and make a big deal over something some random guy said to you anonymously.

Source: X-Surface Tumblr

  1. Marcus Puckett says:

    So that’s what that stupid looking Yahoo! story was about. I was going to say that looked stupid and impossible, especially if they were trying to say that it would work for movies as well.

  2. Michael Sicely says:

    Hot damn, this man got them good.

  3. Softshellcrab says:

    Glad that someone finally got a stab at this absolutely broken system.

  4. Cruz says:

    Rusemaster strikes again.

  5. Kent says:

    Yahoo is still around?

    • serpen1 says:

      It just sort of… exists. It’s probably a front for some online criminal organization, noone cares to look past accidentally clicking on their homepage to check.

  6. anon says:

    “do nothing but copy & paste from other sites, and will willingly publish information without fact checking a single thing or attempting to verify the source.”

    Thank god GYP has never done that. *cough*

    • Delio Pera says:

      I don’t believe we’ve ever directly copy-and-pasted. Do we use other sites for sources? Yes.

  7. Aeiou says:

    So wait are you trying to imply 3D ISNT disgusting?

    I’m confused here buddy.

  8. Metaru Geah says:

    This is fucking sensational

  9. gconway says:

    Vg247 typical they ran it,and dave cook probably gave the ok considering his rep and mr ps3 etc…

  10. gconway says:

    I see rob from cvg got called out aswell..

  11. Dushanan says:

    I like how the articles at the end were all from Kotaku.

  12. Ivan says:

    Is this article about video games?

  13. GonnaGetDruids says:

    Oh wow, Kotaku still allows Brian Ashcraft to write? Well, they let Patricia Hernendez write, so I guess they’re consistent.

  14. Somewanwan says:

    “You don’t see us writing about [insert three kotaku articles here]”

    Hey. At least pick on someone that is at least… not kotaku.

  15. Dio Brando says:

    Oh god, this got them good.

You can use basic HTML in your post. Gather Your Party will never share your email address with anyone, ever.